Episode 5 of Agatha All Along serves up some of the series’ most crucial moments. With the long-awaited reveal of Teen’s identity, a harrowing trial for Agatha, and the ominous presence of the Salem Seven, the episode is a masterclass in tension and character development. Let’s break down all the major twists and hidden details, uncover the episode’s comic book connections, and explore what it all means for the future of the series.
Teen’s Identity Finally Revealed: Wiccan Emerges
Since the premiere of Agatha All Along, fans have been speculating about the true identity of Joe Locke’s character, who has been referred to as “Teen.” Episode 5 finally delivers the answer: Teen is none other than Billy Kaplan, a.k.a. Wiccan, the reincarnated son of Scarlet Witch, Wanda Maximoff. This reveal, with its massive implications, not only for the show but for the wider Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), is a moment that resonates deeply with the audience, connecting them more closely to Wiccan’s journey.
The reveal begins subtly when Teen angrily confronts Agatha after the death of Alice, a member of the coven. When Agatha taunts him by saying, “You’re so much like your mother,” it sets off a chain reaction that culminates in Teen unleashing blue magical energy from his hands—identical to the powers his comic book counterpart Wiccan wields. The camera then pans to Teen, now wearing a blue crown reminiscent of Scarlet Witch’s red tiara, symbolizing his transformation into Wiccan. The headpiece marks him as the reincarnated son of Wanda, a massive nod to the Young Avengers comics, where Wiccan eventually takes on a leadership role as a powerful magic user.
Interestingly, during this scene, Billie Eilish’s song “You Should See Me in a Crown” plays as Wiccan’s powers emerge, adding a fun layer of irony to the moment. The connection between Billy’s crown and Wanda’s tiara is another visual cue that Wiccan’s journey is only beginning, with powerful implications for his future in the MCU.
Wiccan in the Comics: What Does It Mean for the Series?
In the comics, Billy Kaplan (Wiccan) is one of Wanda Maximoff’s twin sons, along with his brother Tommy, who later becomes Speed. Wanda initially created both boys using her reality-altering powers but lost them after she lost control of her abilities. Later, Billy and Tommy’s souls reincarnated into new bodies, and Billy eventually became Wiccan, a key member of the Young Avengers.
For Agatha All Along, this reveal suggests that Teen, as a Wiccan, will play a significant role in the upcoming MCU stories. It also opens the door to a potential reunion with Wanda Maximoff, who is presumed dead after the events of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Teen’s blue energy is a visual cue from the comics, further tying him to his mother’s legacy and setting the stage for future conflicts or alliances. These potential plot twists leave the audience intrigued and excited for what’s to come.
In the comics, Wiccan is not just a spellcaster but one of the most powerful magic users in the Marvel universe. His abilities extend to manipulating reality, controlling timelines, and even elemental powers like fire, water, and wind. Given these powers, his journey in the MCU could evolve into something much more epic.
Agatha’s Trial: Confronting Her Dark Past
Much of Episode 5 centers on Agatha Harkness facing her trial on the Witches’ Road. This road is not only a physical path but a symbolic journey that forces the witches to confront their deepest fears and darkest secrets. Agatha’s trial takes place under a blood moon, a supernatural event that signals the thinning of the veil between life and death, making it the perfect time for spirits to wreak havoc.
The trial begins when the coven, led by Lilia and Jen, finds a Ouija board in the retro 80s-themed cabin—a clever nod to WandaVision’s blend of classic television nostalgia with supernatural elements. The coven attempts to use the board to communicate with the dead. Initially, Agatha plays it off, pretending to be possessed by the spirit of Mrs. Hart, another reference to WandaVision. But things take a dark turn when the spirit of Agatha’s mother, Evanora Harkness, emerges.
Evanora, who Agatha killed during the Salem Witch Trials, appears to take revenge on her daughter. This callback to WandaVision adds layers to Agatha’s character, showing the profound trauma she still carries from that fateful event. Evanora berates Agatha, calling her “born evil” and claiming she should have killed her at birth. This moment underscores the cyclical nature of trauma and revenge that defines many of the witches’ relationships in the series.
An interesting pop culture nod occurs when the witches reach the cabin. The setup evokes Stranger Things with its retro board games and figures, and there’s even a poster for Point Reyes, a location featured in The Fog (1980) and its 2005 remake. The foggy atmosphere in those films is paralleled here when the spirits come for revenge, much like the ghosts in those movies.
The Salem Seven: Vengeful Children of Agatha’s Original Coven
The Salem Seven, introduced in Episode 5, are the children of the witches Agatha killed during the Salem Witch Trials. In the comics, the Salem Seven are the offspring of Nicholas Scratch, Agatha’s son, and they play a crucial role in magical conflicts. In Agatha All Along, however, they are depicted as feral, animal-like creatures hell-bent on revenge.
In this series, the Salem Seven use a magical process called “Hexen Besen,” or witches’ broom, to escape from danger. This intriguing method involves breaking branches from trees and chanting spells together, ensuring that no single witch can fly on a broom without another’s help. This is a fun twist on traditional witch imagery, adding a unique layer to their flight methods compared to other franchises like Harry Potter.
After the witches discover that the Seven are closing in on them, Teen suggests using brooms to fly away, a nod to classic witch imagery. Although the coven initially resists, mocking the brooms as symbols of outdated domesticity, they have no choice but to use them to escape. This sequence adds a lighthearted moment to an otherwise intense episode, with the witches soaring through the sky under the light of the blood moon, only to be forced back to the ground as the Witches’ Road pulls them back to face Agatha’s trial.
The Salem Seven represents a looming threat that adds tension to the episode, constantly pushing the coven closer to danger. Their whispered chants of “Find her. Find them” create an eerie atmosphere as they hunt Agatha and her group. These creatures embody the consequences of Agatha’s past sins, literally and figuratively chasing her down the road.
Alice’s Sacrifice: Agatha’s Dark Magic Unleashed
One of the most heartbreaking moments of the episode is Alice’s death. Alice, in a selfless act of bravery, attempts to save Agatha from her mother’s possession by blasting her with magical energy. However, in a tragic twist, Agatha begins to absorb Alice’s powers, draining her life force, much like she did to her coven in WandaVision. Agatha insists that it was unintentional, but the damage is done—Alice dies, leaving the rest of the coven in shock and further alienating Agatha from her allies. The emotional weight of Alice’s sacrifice is palpable, making the audience feel the gravity of the situation.
This moment is significant because it reaffirms Agatha’s darker tendencies. Although she is positioned as the protagonist in Agatha All Along, moments like these remind the audience of her morally ambiguous nature. Agatha’s ability to absorb others’ magic is both her greatest strength and her most dangerous trait, as it leaves those around her vulnerable.
After Alice’s death, the Ouija board spells out “Nicholas Scratch,” which rattles Agatha, suggesting that his presence may be lingering or that he might return in some capacity. This raises intriguing possibilities for future episodes and hints at deeper family ties within the story.
The Return of Nicholas Scratch: A New Twist?
As the Ouija board moves on its own after Alice’s death, it spells out a familiar name—Nicholas Scratch. In the comics, Nicholas Scratch is Agatha’s son, and his mention in this episode raises questions about his potential involvement in future episodes. Could Nicholas Scratch be another key player in the trials of the Witches’ Road? Or is this simply a callback to Agatha’s complex family history?
Hearing the name seems to affect Agatha profoundly, and it momentarily stops her from siphoning Alice’s power. This suggests that Nicholas Scratch might still play an essential role in the story, potentially as a foil to Wiccan or as part of Agatha’s unresolved past.
The Final Confrontation: Wiccan’s Power Unleashed
After Alice’s death, Teen’s grief and anger reach a boiling point. He confronts Agatha, accusing her of selfishly killing those around her to gain power. Agatha responds with a knowing smirk, telling Teen that he is “so much like [his] mother.” This remark, a direct reference to Wanda Maximoff, pushes Teen over the edge, and he unleashes his full magical potential.
In an explosive display of power, Teen possesses Jen and Lilia, forcing them to grab Agatha and throw her into the mud that had threatened to consume them earlier in the episode. The sequence is both shocking and visually stunning, as blue energy crackles from Teen’s hands, further cementing his identity as Wiccan. Jen and Lilia, under Teen’s control, are also cast into the mud, leaving their fates uncertain.
The final shot of Teen, now donning the blue tiara that resembles Scarlet Witch’s iconic headpiece, marks his transformation into Wiccan. This moment is a decisive visual nod to the comics and signals that Wiccan’s journey is just beginning.
Río Vidal: Is She the MCU’s Lady Death?
One of the most intriguing characters in Agatha All Along is Río Vidal, played by Aubrey Plaza. Throughout the series, fans have speculated about her true identity, with many believing she could be the MCU’s version of Lady Death. In Episode 5, Río’s absence during the final confrontation adds fuel to this theory. While Wiccan dispatches the witches, Río is nowhere to be seen, possibly dealing with Alice’s spirit or preparing for her next move.
Río has shown an affinity for death, and her comments about “getting the bodies” if Agatha kills her coven suggest a deeper connection to the forces of life and death. If she is indeed Lady Death, her role in the final episodes could be pivotal, especially in the context of Agatha’s survival or potential downfall.
Her earlier comments about “getting the bodies” of the dead witches seem to confirm that Rio is more than just another member of the coven—she is, in fact, Death herself. This will likely become a key factor in the remaining episodes.
What’s Next for Agatha and Wiccan?
With Teen’s transformation into Wiccan and the coven in disarray, the stage is set for a thrilling conclusion to Agatha All Along. Will Agatha survive the trials of the Witches’ Road? Or will Wiccan’s newfound powers make him the show’s true protagonist, with Agatha becoming the villain once again?
One thing is sure: the final episodes will be filled with twists, intense magical battles, and emotional revelations. With the potential return of Nicholas Scratch and the looming presence of Río Vidal, the stakes have never been higher for Agatha and her coven.
Conclusion
Episode 5 of Agatha All Along may have had its slow moments, but the stylish, magical reveal of Billy Kaplan as Wiccan made the journey worthwhile. The episode combined clever comic book nods, horror elements, and nostalgia-infused settings to create an atmosphere that was both eerie and intriguing.
While the early parts of the episode felt a bit off-key, the final moments—especially Wiccan’s emergence—set the stage for an exciting conclusion. The Billie Eilish song, “You Should See Me in a Crown,” during Billy’s transformation was the perfect touch, and despite its flaws, the episode managed to leave us excited for what’s to come.
As the Witches’ Road narrows and the final trials approach, Agatha All Along is proving itself to be one of the most compelling and character-rich entries in the Marvel universe.
